Men's Drainmaker ATV Shoe

★★

Holes built into sides allow pea-sized pebbles

These shoes had the makings of one of the best Columbia water shoes I have purchased except for the three triangular holes on the outer side of each shoe. These holes place right at the sole are easily large enough to allow pea-sized gravel and other debris in and around your feet between your foot and the insole. Whether for river rafting or general walking around town, this is not acceptable to me. I also do not generally like the indentations on the sole at the middle of the heel nor on the ball of the foot. These seem like unnecessary wear points. The toe on this shoe is great. The rest of the construction seems very good--both sturdy and comfortable. The tread pattern and "stickiness" of the sole seem very good. This shoe might well be a 5 for someone who does not care whether debris gets around their feet. I bought these at another vendor and did not see the side holes in the photos. I have probably owned a half dozen Columbia water shoe models going back to Drainmaker III {which were awesome, btw]

★★★

Light Weight with high quality.

Good quality and fits well. My only concern is with the sole, since I want something more soft and comfy. I would still recommend it anyways.

★★★★★

Great all day water/hiking shoe

Comfortable shoe and stylish. Drains water well. Side holes allow sand and small pebbles in, but also allow them to work their way out. I would suggest going down a size especially if you plan to not wear socks.